Use it or Lose it: 15 years, not 35

Thursday, November 5, 2009 6:55 PST -08:00   News  


p2pnet news view Music | Politics:- Earlier in the month, “Members of Britain’s new Featured Artists Coalition want the European Commission to help them recover their rights to their own music,” I posted here and in a2f2a.com.

As things stand, an EC “use it or lose it” copyright clause means recordings revert to performers if the producer or label no longer wants to market the recording — but only  after half a century, I said, adding:

“However, FAC members, including Billy Bragg, today met with senior civil servants at the Intellectual Property Office in London in a bid to get the cause whittled down to 35 years”

Now, “I agree with the artists,” says Paul Kamp, vice president, business development and corporate counsel at Backbone Networks, a company specializing in internet radio automation services.

He goes on »»»

The act would reduce the term from 50 years to 35 years seems like a lot but with life expectancy being 70 years or so 35 years is half a lifetime.  I would push for a shorter term than 35 years.

Here is my rationale:

  • In the past there was a significant cost associated with publishing.  This ranged from recording the work, manufacturing the record, distributing it to record stores, accounting for the inventory, selling off returns.  With these costs in place the record companies were able to determine how economically viable it was to continue publishing because of the associated expense.
  • Since the work is already recorded those costs are no longer part of the equation, they are sunk costs.  Everything is about distribution.  Yes, I know there is some cost associated with promotion but I think the critical thing is some type of availability.  Further, it is often the artist that would do the promotion.
  • In the age of digital distribution there is no reason for a producer or label to not publish a work.  You can go to a “record service” like TuneCore and get the work published through digital distribution outlets like Amazon’s MP3 Store, Apple’s iTunes, etc.  All for a cost of a little over $100/year.
  • Promotion in the digital world could be fairly inexpensive too.  The artist or record company could provide the works to Internet radio stations for broadcasting with links to purchase in the digital stores.  All the Internet radio stations I know provide links to the digital works for purchase. For example, listen to Pandora on your iPhone, there is a link to purchase the track from the iTunes store.  This is also true for Radio Paradise, Soma FM, AccuRadio , BAGeL Radio and all the stations on the networks we run.  Pretty straight forward distribution and free promotion.  Seems like there is no need to hold back on distribution after a work is recorded.

As a compromise, perhaps push for a shorter term, i.e. 15 years and have the artists pay for publishing and distribution.  If it means something to the record companies  I am sure they can come up with the fee to pay the digital distributor.  There seems to be no reason to hold back on publishing the older works.

At least none that I can come up with.

Is there a reason to maintain these extended periods when the company is doing nothing to benefit from the work?

The switch to digital has impacted the whole music ecosystem from record companies to radio stations to record stores to promotion to bands to how everything gets packaged.

“Enabling the distribution rights to revert back to the artists would enable them to experiment with promotion and distribution,” says Paul, adding:

“The record companies, by their inaction on certain works, should relinquish their right over those works and let the artists who created those works benefit.”

He promises to post an article on the Backbone Networks blog about how “costs have transitioned dramatically”.

Jon Newton – p2pnet

Follow p2pnet on Twitter.

1p Subscribe

First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win ~ Mahatma Gandhi

November, 2009


Use free p2pnet newsfeeds for your site. It’s really easy!
Subscribe to p2pnet.net | | rss feed: http://p2pnet.net/p2p.rss | | Mobile – http://p2pnet.net/index-wml.php


Net access blocked by government restrictions? Use Psiphon from the Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto. Go here for details.

Related Articles

  • Baidu ‘not a music pirate’
  • The Beatles: 21st century holdouts
  • Cut ‘use it or lose it’ clause to 35 years, artists say
  • ‘Pesky consumer rights … ‘


  •  Del.Icio.Us this! | Digg this! | Reddit this! | Stumble this!

     Enjoyed this? Subscribe to the feed.

    No comments yet

    Leave a Comment

    You must be logged in to post a comment.


     
    Ares Free Music Downloads- Get it Today!
    Are You A Music Lover? Then You Need Ares!
    Worry and Hassle Free Music — Ares
    Great Music Is At Ares
    Ares Free Download Review
     
    Ares A Quality Program For Downloading Media
    .
    Free Ares for All
    .
    Ares Destiny Review
    .
    Advantages of Ares
    .
    Sharing Files With Ares Is Quick Easy and Fun
    .
     
     
     
    . Ares P2P
    . Ares is the ultimate photos and pictures download tool
    . Ares movie download
    . Downloading music with Ares – it’s so easy!
    . Ares is person to person download tool
     
     
    Acai Berry | Salvia | Ares Free Music Downloads Home
    Copyright © 2010 Official Ares All Rights Reserved.