Limewire case thrown out of court
P2P filesharing service Limewire has had a spanner thrown into the works after a federal judge in the US dismissed claims that the RIAA had illegally blocked Limewire’s attempts at creating a legitimate digital music service.
Last year, the RIAA sued Limewire for copyright infringement. Limewire responded with a counter-claim, accusing the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) of price fixing, hacking Limewire user accounts, promoting lies about Limewire being involved in child pornography rings and urging musicians not to deal with filesharing networks.
It was ruled this week that Limewire has no case. Representatives from Limewire were unable to prove that price fixing had directly affected the service.
Limewire’s claim that the RIAA had tried to get all filesharing services to sell up to iMesh, the only P2P music retailer approved by the RIAA, were thrown out after Limewire failed to support its claims — in spite of the federal judge finding that Limewire had been specifically harmed in this way.
The judge said, “In sum, LimeWire has failed to plead facts plausibly suggesting a ‘meeting of the minds’ among any of the [labels] to refuse ‘reasonable access’ to their hashes.”
Further claims by Limewire that the RIAA had attempted to create a “shared monopoly” were also thrown out on lack of evidence.
All Limewire claims were dismissed and the ruling cannot be appealed or overturned. Limewire had its chance and blew it. This is a major blow for the filesharing network and shows a lack of legal experience and preparation.
We can only hope that Limewire is able to bounce back after this ruling. The Internet needs Limewire.
Related Articles
Del.Icio.Us this! | Digg this! | Reddit this! | Stumble this!
Joe 14Dec07
LIMEWIRE IS ILLEGAL!!!! ILLEGAL!!! Get over it. Its llegal, and anyone who’s downloaded it is a criminal. Don’t do LimeWire, folks!
Vanalli 18Dec07
Limewire in itself is not illegal.
vicious gurl 19Dec07
f–k u joe bite me ur a BITCH AND CONSIDER TAKING UR HEAD OUT OF UR ASS SHITHEAD!!!
STACY 21Dec07
WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO TELL I THINK THAT IT IS NOT RIGHT HOW ARE U GOINH TO PUT THAT ITS FREE. THIER NOTHING ON HERE FREE U HAVE TO A CERID CARD AND EVERYONE HAS THAT. PLUS ITS NOT FREE IF YOU U WONT MOENY.
Vague study into filesharing speeds leaves a lot to be desired 22Feb08
[...] The clever folks at consumer-reviews.us recently did a “study” of filesharing programs to figure out which one was fastest for free music downloads. The music download comparisons were performed with a number of top filesharing services, including one of our favorites, Limewire. [...]
iTunes still top for legal music downloads - Music download news and reviews 26Feb08
[...] iTunes also boasts a huge catalogue of more than six million songs. According to NPD, almost half of all US teens did not buy a CD in 2007, instead choosing to get music downloads either through services like iTunes, or else filesharing programs like Ares or Limewire. [...]
More music, more filesharing, less money | Ares Free Music Downloads 26Feb08
[...] 20% of all Internet users, including us, used filesharing programs like Ares or Limewire last year. Hurray for us. Filesharing is also rampant among US teens. What this tells us is that [...]
Filesharing student stands up to RIAA - Music downloads, news and reviews 02Mar08
[...] It’s not a matter of principle, but rather common sense. The law is the law and if you find yourself with a hefty fine, you have to pay it. One student at the University of Maryland University College, who goes by the name of Jessica, refused to pay the out-of-court settlement after being caught sharing nearly 300 songs with the filesharing program Limewire. [...]